Comeback Specials

20% off selected pins & keychains/charms. 15% off selected pin sets. Automatically applied at checkout.

Filter by
Sort by
Sort by

78 products

Sleeping Kitty Collection - Reecie - Special Edition, Charity Pin, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Sleeping Reecie Pin
From $19.95 $24.95
20% OFF

8 reviews
Witch Kitty - Tiny Enamel Pin (Halloween, Kawaii Cat Pin), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Witch Kitty Mini Pin
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

13 reviews
Halloween Kitties, Set of 5
Quick buy
Halloween Kitties Enamel Pin Set (Set of 5)
From $13.55 $16.95
15% OFF SETS

24 reviews
Pumpkin Kitty - Tiny Enamel Pin (Halloween, Kawaii Cat, Hard Enamel Pin), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Pumpkin Kitty Mini Pin
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

7 reviews
Charm Trio Keychain - Pot Plant Kitties
Quick buy
Pot Plant Kitties - Keychain Mini Trio
$25.45 $29.95
20% OFF
Pot Plant Kitties - Pin Collection, Set of 9 Enamel Pins
Quick buy
Pot Plant Kitties Pin Collection - Set of 9 Pins
$152.95 $179.95
15% OFF SETS
Swinging Kitties - Keychain Mini Trio
Quick buy
Swinging Kitties - Keychain Mini Trio
$23.95 $29.95
20% OFF
Purrmaid Boogie Glow-in-the-dark Pin
Quick buy
Purrmaid Boogie Glow-in-the-dark Pin
$15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

3 reviews
Mix'n'Match Pot Plant & Swinging Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pin Set + Keychain
Quick buy
Mix'n'Match Pot Plant & Swinging Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pin Set + Keychain
$84.95 $99.95
UP TO 20% OFF
Swinging Kitties Pin Set, , Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Swinging Kitties Pin Set
$33.95 $39.95
15% OFF SETS
Jazz Kitties Collection - Double Bass Kitty - Small Enamel Pin (All Fluffed Up Pin & Sticker Club), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Jazz Kitty, Double Bass Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

3 reviews
Flying Broomstick Witch Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Witch Broomstick Cat Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

4 reviews
Cat in a Witch Hat
Quick buy
Witch Brew Cat Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

3 reviews
Ghost Kitty - Tiny Enamel Pin (Halloween, Cat Lapel Pin, Hard Enamel Pin), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

8 reviews
Ghost Kitty, Gonnagetcha - Tiny Enamel Pin, Halloween Cat Pin, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin, Eager
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

3 reviews
Jazz Kitties Collection - Piano Kitty - Small Enamel Pin (All Fluffed Up Pin & Sticker Club), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Jazz Kitty, Piano Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF

1 review
Kitty-in-a-Box, Ginny Pin
Quick buy
Kitty-in-a-Box, Ginny Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF

1 review
Balloon Kitty Enamel Pins (Set of 3)
Quick buy
Balloon Kitties – Dangle Pin Set (Set of 3)
From $17.55 $21.95
15% OFF SETS
Frankenkitty Pin
Quick buy
Frankenkitty Pin
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

2 reviews
Jazz Kitties Collection - Saxophone Kitty - Small Enamel Pin (All Fluffed Up Pin & Sticker Club), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Jazz Kitty, Saxophone Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

2 reviews
Sticker Sheet - Ghost Kitties
Quick buy
Sticker Sheet - Ghost Kitties
$4.20 $4.95
15% OFF SETS

9 reviews
Mix'n'Match Swinging Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pins (Set of 3)
Quick buy
Mix'n'Match Swinging Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pins (Set of 3)
From $21.60 $27.00
UP TO 20% OFF
Hungry Hungry Icecream Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Hungry Hungry Icecream Kitty Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF

1 review
Mummified Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Mummified Kitty Pin
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

2 reviews
Mix'n'Match Pot Plant Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pins (Set of 3)
Quick buy
Mix'n'Match Pot Plant Kitties – Magnetised Dangle Pins (Set of 3)
From $21.60 $27.00
UP TO 20% OFF
Ghost Kitty, Spooky - Tiny Enamel Pin, Mini Cat Pin, Halloween, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin, Spooky
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

2 reviews
Kitty-in-a-Box, Moonpie Pin
Quick buy
Kitty-in-a-Box, Moonpie Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF

1 review
Kitty-in-a-Box, Pin Set of 6
Quick buy
Kitty-in-a-Box, Pin Set of 6
$59.50 $69.95
15% OFF SETS
Snake Plant Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Snake Plant Kitty Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF
PREORDER Ghost Kitties Set C, Set of 4 - Tiny Enamel Pins, Mini Pin Set
Quick buy
Ghost Kitties Set C, Set of 4 - Tiny Enamel Pins, Mini Pin Set
From $36.30 $42.70
15% OFF SETS

1 review
Swinging Kitty Keychain 1.5"
Quick buy
Spotted Swinging Kitty Keychain
$15.95 $19.95
20% OFF
Jazz Kitty, Drums Pin
Quick buy
Jazz Kitty, Drums Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

1 review
Sleeping Kitties, Set of 4 Pins
Quick buy
Sleeping Kitties, Set of 4 Pins
$42.45 $49.95
15% OFF SETS
Sticker Sheet - Halloween Kitties (2" x 7"), Sticker Sheet, Decorative Stickers
Quick buy
Sticker Sheet - Halloween Kitties
$4.20 $4.95
15% OFF SETS

4 reviews
Cat in a Witch Hat - Set of 3 Pins
Quick buy
Cat in a Witch Hat - Set of 3 Pins
$42.45 $49.95
15% OFF SETS

4 reviews
Birds Nest Fern Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Birds Nest Fern Kitty Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF
Hungry Hungry Burger Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Hungry Hungry Burger Kitty Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF
Hungry Hungry Junk Food Kitties - Set of 4 Pins
Quick buy
Hungry Hungry Junk Food Kitties - Set of 4 Pins
$42.45 $49.95
15% OFF SETS
Blue Balloon Kitty Dangle Pin
Quick buy
Blue Balloon Kitty Dangle Pin
From $19.95 $24.95
20% OFF

15 reviews
Pink Balloon Kitty Dangle Pin
Quick buy
Pink Balloon Kitty Dangle Pin
From $19.95 $24.95
20% OFF

15 reviews
Ghost Kitty, Happy - Tiny Enamel Pin, Mini Pin, Cat Hard Enamel Pin, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin, Happy
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

1 review
Ghost Kitty, Sad - Tiny Enamel Pin, Halloween Cat Pin, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin, Worried
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF

1 review
Ghost Kitty, Hmph! - Tiny Enamel Pin, Halloween Cat Pin, Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Ghost Kitty Pin, Smug
From $13.55 $16.95
20% OFF
Sleeping Kitty Collection - Sherman - Enamel Pin *EXCLUSIVE* (All Fluffed Up Pin & Sticker Club), Pins, Brooches & Lapel Pins
Quick buy
Sleeping Sherman on Cloud Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

1 review
Sleeping Kitty on Moon Pin
Quick buy
Sleeping Kitty on Moon Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF

1 review
Kitty-in-a-Box, Olivia Pin
Quick buy
Kitty-in-a-Box, Olivia Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF
Kitty-in-a-Box, Smokey Pin
Quick buy
Kitty-in-a-Box, Smokey Pin
From $15.15 $18.95
20% OFF

2 reviews
String of Nickels Kitty Keychain Mini
Quick buy
String of Nickels Kitty Keychain Mini
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF
Prayer Plant Kitty Keychain Mini
Quick buy
Prayer Plant Kitty Keychain Mini
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF
Donkey's Tail Kitty Pin
Quick buy
Donkey's Tail Kitty Pin
From $15.95 $19.95
20% OFF